Black Cats, Black Magic, and Black Friday … sounds like a threesome to avoid.
But untold millions will be lining up the day after Thanksgiving in the wee hours of the morning with steely-eyed focus and adrenaline pumping – all with the almighty bargain in mind.
Maybe it’s a gender thing, but while you might find me up at 5am to go fishing, you’ll never find me caffeined-up and ready to shop at that time of day. Maybe Black Friday is defined less by gender and more by the American way. We’re competitive and like to win. And, after a year of economic suffering like we’ve had in this country, you can’t blame consumers for wanting to taste even a small victory.
But as any coach worth his salt will tell you, winning comes at a price. Unfortunately, the price of playing the Black Friday game reached an all time high in 2008 when a Walmart worker was trampled to death by a mob of shoppers at a store in Long Island. The repercussions have been strong and retailers are taking steps to calm the crowds and bring order to stores as the holiday season kicks off this coming Friday.
Walmart settled the lawsuits that followed with a nearly $2 Million payout to victims of the incident. Concern is so high that even the National Retail Federation (NRF) has released crowd management guidelines for its members hoping to prevent future disasters.
Consumers seeking ways to get ahead of the game have options. They can check out Top 10 Black Friday websites to find bargains in advance, or they can just sit at home after turkey dinner on Thursday and watch “what not to do” videos on YouTube ranging from Stampedes at Walmart to Scuffles at Target.
Outside of the fun that some people associate with the crazed energy of Black Friday, I have to wonder if retailers knew what they doing when they originally promoted the concept. Competing on price only leads to a “death spiral” of diminishing profit margins. And since there is usually only one acknowledged price leader in a discounting category (ahem, Walmart) the rest of the retailing pack might be much better off taking a higher road to open consumer wallets in their favor.
There have been some really good articles written about the violence of last year’s Black Friday, and academics such as University of Delaware professor Sharron Lennon are now studying the human behaviors that lead to such incidents. There is also a groundswell of voices encouraging consumers to “Spend time together, not money”.
All of this makes me smile when people ask if Loyalty Marketing programs work. Yep, there are some lame versions of the concept out there, and even the good ones could make use of their data to be more relevant to their customers. But as a business owner, it should be attractive to preserve margins, improve the shopping experience, and justify repeat business at your store without having to fake a “going out of business sale” once a month. Data-driven Customer Strategies do just that.
I’ll bet there are some forward thinking people at the NRF and among larger retailers that could change the paradigm. Maybe the time has come to return a bit of elegance and class into daily shopping experiences, not to mention air travel. And, retailers had better consider the impact of promoting mass shopping frenzy on Millennial (Generation Y) consumers shopping online at home from their PC’s.
Could it be time for Black Friday to “Go Dark”?